Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Others Best Bang for Your Buck Benjamin?

Ezana4CE

Master HAMster
1,975
4,630
Texas
Airguns of Arizona - 10% discount
Airguns of Arizona - 10% discount
Country flag
Last edited:
First I'd like to say that I was wondering if the Marauder was still relevant considering that the Cayden has established a place in the market. For those who have owned and shot both, what are the main differences between the two? Are these the best bang for your buck small bore Benjamin PCP rifles? Where would the Armada fit in?

As for bullpups, there's the Akela and the Bulldog which are in two completely different lanes and do not compare.

And there are the Gunnar, Kratos, and Fortitude. I don't know much about these.

Finally, I can't leave out the Marauder pistol aka the Prod. I have included it because I shoot mine exclusively in carbine configuration.

I'm biased and partial to the Bulldog platform in .357. Ammo is not cheap and you do not get a high shot count from a stock Bulldog. While it stacks up well to comparable rifles from other manufactures, it doesn't compare to any other Benjamin air rifles that I am aware of and are presently in production. With a .357 Bulldog can shoot pellets, slugs, and air bolts from it. As for the M357 Bulldog, I'm a bit apprehensive about shooting air bolts from it because I think they will carry enough energy to easily penetrate my target advertised to stop all bolts and my backstop, ultimately destroying the bolts. I like to hunt so the versatility in projectiles is beneficial to me. I shoot more slugs than anything, but shooting air bolts is exciting. Pellets are a pretty affordable option of the three, but you only get 100 per tin. I stopped looking at the cost per shot factor because I enjoy shooting the platform so much which makes to the best bang for my buck Benjamin gun. I also own a Marauder Pistol. I've done my fair share of hunting with it taking squirrels, rabbits, and snakes. I still love this Bulldog platform as I've taken much larger animals with it. It's easy to work on, parts are affordable and easy to obtain, and service is readily available for mods and fixes that are beyond my current abilities.

.357 Benjamin Bulldog with a Seneca Air Bolt loaded
Bnejamin Bulldog .357 w:Donny FL encap adapter Loaded w:.35 Seneca Airbiolt .jpg
Benajmin Bulldog .357 in Turret rest and Seneca .35 air bolts in box.jpg

Bulldog M357 set up to be shot tethered.
Benjamin M357.jpg


So I ask you, what's the best bang for your buck Benjamin PCP air rifle?
 
I’ve always been fan of the Marauders-
Gen1 .22 was laser hole in hole precision.
I got the 20 Cal Marauder @ Airgun Revisions on my radar. I’ve Wanted a .20 PCP for long time, for some medium to long Range Chipmunk control, think would excellent for that.
 
I have a Cayden, a .177 Marauder, and a Marauder pistol. The Cayden is the most well made in my opinion. Everything works flawlessly but it is very pellet picky. Only likes AA 18’s but can shoot sub MOA at 50 yards. Verdict is still out on the Marauder rifle. This is my newest gun and I am just not seeing the accuracy I expected. Have ran 17 different pellets through it the Quin Yaung domes show the most promise for now. My Marauder pistol is my go to pesting gun it is a tack driver. Hundreds of starling carcasses attest to it’s proficiency. I use this gun 4 to 5 times a week. So for ease of use and practicality my P-rod is my best bang for my buck.
 
I've been eyeballing a Cayden for a while. the only negative I've read about it is that it is on the heavy side. I think it may make a nice squirrel and rabbit rifle. I like the look of that wood stock.
 
The Cayden is a great gun. The entire cocking mechanism is very smooth and precise. The trigger is a little heavy but some videos show how to adjust it. This gun is loud though. You definitely need a moderator. I don’t think you would be disappointed if you got one.
 
I’d recommend the Turkish made Cayden over a Marauder if you are in the market. The Cayden is not what I would call “heavy” at all. It’s a comfortable rifle to carry in the woods, has a smooth action and great shot count and accuracy.
The Armada or the Marauder used to be a great starting point for custom projects but there is now a definite decline in interest in them which means the aftermarket goodies are eventually going to dry up. Crosman hasn’t made any moves toward refining and improving the Marauder over the years and it’s just being left behind as other manufacturers are bringing out products that are better engineered in the same price range. The fact that Crosmans best offerings are now Turkish manufactured rebranded airguns says a lot about the direction the company has moved in. This is not necessarily a bad thing, I very much like the Cayden and the Kratos and would have bought the Kyro if they would have followed through and brought it to market as well. I’d rather have great quality Turkish made stuff than stale leftovers from the US.
I’d like to clarify though, I’d much rather have American-made greatness than anything else though. (Thank you American Air Arms for providing airgunners with just that!)
The Cayden is just a solid rifle with solid performance that will satisfy many peoples needs as it is, with little or no tinkering needed. The Kratos is as well, but with a higher shot count and incredibly consistent shot strings. Both rifles are capable of pretty impressive accuracy at 50 yds.
You are already familiar with the standard Benjamin products like the Prod, so I’d like to encourage you to check out the Cayden or the Kratos and see for yourself how it stacks up against the Marauder. They will put a smile on your face.
 
Bang for the buck Marauder is a .25 caliber Marauder old enough (Gen 2 has better parts availability) to have the Green Mountain barrel. Mine is very good with JSB pellets, 870 fps. Dial and shoot with a 6-24 scope out to 100 yds. My only wish is that it held more air.
 
I had the Kratos in 22cal. Great deal for the money and very accurate. The only weakness with that the shroud was weak when you put a moderator on. Outside of that I though it was a great airgun for the money.
 
I have an M357 Bulldog, a PRod .22 in a custom Teak wood stock from Airgun Revisions, an Akela .22 and my newest Akela .177. I bought the .177 Akela to try my hand at HFT this year. I really like the way the Akelas shoulder. I e not spent a lot of time with my Bulldog, I bought it to have for when PA hopefully adopts airguns for large game use. So I can’t even begin to say how it shoots pellets or slugs consistently. I took it to the range once with slugs and it did alright at 50 yards, printing a 1.5 inch group with 140 gr slugs. Pellets, I have no idea…yet 😁.

The Prod? Is a chipmunk slayer out to 30-40 yards. Awesome little carbine. So fun to shoot.

Both Akelas have been improved by Airgun Revisions drop in hammer spring kits and the .177 is showing great potential as my entry into HFT this year as well as a possible 50 yard bench gun. The .22 Akela I know will do well at bench.

As far as the best bang, I couldn’t possibly choose one over the other honestly. But if I had to choose one, it would be the PRod because it’s proven itself on paper and souls. Pigeons, starlings, house sparrows, chipmunks, & squirrels alike have fallen to it. IMG_4167.webp7A659DD0-4BA9-4330-9E0D-DA103DE2F9F6.webpIMG_3847.webpIMG_3524.webpIMG_0684.webp
 
@PA_AirHead Don’t count out that M357. Which 140 grain slugs are we talking about that you’re shooting 1.5” at 50 yards? Who makes them? Which type of base and nose do these slugs have? Have you chronographed any projectiles from the M357?
 
@PA_AirHead Don’t count out that M357. Which 140 grain slugs are we talking about that you’re shooting 1.5” at 50 yards? Who makes them? Which type of base and nose do these slugs have? Have you chronographed any projectiles from the M357?
Listed in order of photos….

So I have 145 gr (I misspoke on the 140) Custom Lead Solutions which are what I shot so far for a group.

I also have 142 gr NSA slugs I will try this summer.

And then I have 155 gr hand poured from a great friend of mine to try out. His shoot great out of his AAA Slayer at 100 yards, so I’m hopeful that I will get the same results.

The only saved string I have was from FX Hybrids at 68 gr. IMG_4348.webpIMG_4349.webpIMG_4350.webpIMG_4351.webpIMG_4352.webpIMG_4353.webpIMG_4354.webpIMG_4355.webpIMG_4348.webpIMG_4349.webpIMG_4350.webpIMG_4351.webpIMG_4352.webpIMG_4353.webpIMG_4354.webpIMG_4355.webp
 
@PA_AirHead Thank you. I have shot the 145 grain Custom Solutions Fireball slugs and determined that they shoot acceptably from within 60 yards. Aside from that, I would recommend that you definitely buy some 110 grain NSA HP-DB slugs and Griffin Airgun Ammo 145 grain hollow-point rebated-boattail slugs (I think he lists them as boattail slugs). 81 grain, .35 JSB Match Diabolo pellets group within 1” at 50 yards from a somewhat stable shooting rest. I’m sure there are others, but these have been proven in my somewhat extensive testing and hunting with the M357.
 
@PA_AirHead Thank you. I have shot the 145 grain Custom Solutions Fireball slugs and determined that they shoot acceptably from within 60 yards. Aside from that, I would recommend that you definitely buy some 110 grain NSA HP-DB slugs and Griffin Airgun Ammo 145 grain hollow-point rebated-boattail slugs (I think he lists them as boattail slugs). 81 grain, .35 JSB Match Diabolo pellets group within 1” at 50 yards from a somewhat stable shooting rest. I’m sure there are others, but these have been proven in my somewhat extensive testing and hunting with the M357.
I do have some very dirty looking ZAN slugs to try as well. I also do have the JSB pellets and also the JSB Hades to try out. I can’t think that the pellets will be all that stable at what I figure will be well in excess of 1000 fps. But we’ll see. Testing is some of the fun of our sport. I will definitely pick up some of those NSA & Griffin to try out. 🤜🏻🤛🏻. Thank you.
 
Last edited:
I do have some very dirty looking ZAN slugs to try as well. I also do have the JSB pellets and also the JSB Hades to try out. I can’t think that the pellets will be all that stable at what I figure will be well in excess of 1000 fps. But we’ll see. Testing is some of the fun of our sport. I will definitely pick up some of those NSA & Griffin to try out. 🤜🏻🤛🏻. Thank you.
@PA_AirHead I don’t use Zan projectiles. I tried them once in another rifle and had issues with them. Here’s a shot string with the 81 grain .35 JSB Match Diabolos
IMG_4420.jpeg

Stability appears to be ok at 50 yards.

Edit: here’s a 2”x2” target (the dark green area is 4”x4”) shot from about 50 yards with the JSB 81 grain Diabolo pellets.
IMG_4421.jpeg
 
That’s zinging em!! I’m looking forward to warmer weather 😁
@PA_AirHead Yea this gun can send them. The shot in the 862 fps range was a double loaded shot I believe.

I have a Prod as well. Not a lot of power, but it’s consistent and pretty easy to maintain. I’ve taken squirrels, rabbit, and a snake with my Prod. Great little lightweight woods walker for small game. I met my match when I tried to take a raccoon. Don’t even think about trying to take a raccoon with a regular Prod. I think the pellet bounced off its skull.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create FREE account

Create a FREE account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Trending in this forum

Back
Top